Only Angelina Jolie’s second directorial effort, Unbroken is
a very beautiful film to look at. Granted, she did herself a solid by retaining
the services of celebrated director of photography, Roger Deakins, one of the
premiere cinematographers working today. Unfortunately, the rest of the film
falls flat, with an uneven pace, odd structure (at least at first), and too
steadfast a dedication to telling every single step of Louis Zamperini’s (Jack
O’Connell) amazing survival story that it’s ultimately unable to set itself
apart from any standard, triumph-of-the-human-spirit type tale.
Zamperini’s story is incredible, no doubt: starting from
troubled early days as a punk kid in Depression-era Torrance, California, he
went on to compete in the 1936 Olympics in Berlin. Though he finished eighth in
the 5,000-meter race, he recorded the fastest final lap, which caught the
attention of Hitler, who insisted on a personal meeting (a moment noticeably
absent in the film). Later, serving as a bombardier in World War II, his
cobbled together B-24 crashed, and he spent 47 days on a life raft bobbing
around in the shark-infested Pacific Ocean, trying not to die in a number of
ways before finding rescue through a Japanese navy ship. The remainder of the
war he spent brutalized in various POW camps.
“How much can befall one man?”, you may ask, and Zamperini’s
is the kind of story you wouldn’t believe unless you already knew it to be
true. Think Forrest Gump—only real. Based on Laura
Hildenbrand’s biography, Unbroken: A World War II Story of
Survival, Resilience, and Redemption, and adapted by Joel and Ethan
Coen, Unbroken is at the mercy of Jolie’s
commitment to convincing the audience that the story is, in fact, not
exaggerated. She faithfully recounts every step on Zamperini’s harrowing
journey, to a fault.
The film bursts to life with a tense bombing mission, early
scenes intercut with flashbacks to Zamperini’s childhood and his career as a
runner. This jarring structure is thankfully abandoned after the first act, the
remaining sequence of events told in chronological order, but eventually every
occurrence starts to feel sadistic, like the film is piling horror upon horror,
relentlessly, without looking to any greater meaning or purpose. Of course,
this is how it happened, but by leaving nothing out the story loses all focus.
It’s very episodic: this happened; then this happened; and then he was taken
here. It’s a blow-by-blow account, a herky-jerky space the predictable result,
so as a narrative, Unbroken never builds; instead
of an arc, it’s a remains a flat line. The film merely trundles along, hitting
main points, and then the Bird (Takamasa Ishihara), a sadistic POW camp guard,
whacks Louis in the face with a bamboo rod a bunch of times. Cue end credits.
All which could be forgiven if the film had anything else in
mind besides showing Zamperini’s trials and tribulations bluntly. His younger
days are little more than his brother telling him to shape up, passing along
empty slogans like “If you can take it, you can make it” and “A moment of pain
is worth a lifetime of glory,” so that when we hear such advice and bromides
later it all makes sense. Early on in the film, during the war scenes,
everything seems fine; we may be thrust into the midst of heated combat, but the
guys are all friends, Zamperini’s well liked, and when people die, it’s
shrugged off. Even in the camps, Louis’s pummeling is pretty much all that
happens. Almost no one talks; scenes are comprised primarily of American
soldiers looking grubby and sad while Louis stands defiant, the holy hell beat
out of him. Then there’s the running; so damn much running.
The film’s only attempt to form any bond with any characters
besides Louis occurs when he sits aboard the life raft, post-crash, with Phil
(Domhnall Gleeson) and Mac (Finn Wittrock). The three survivors struggle to
catch fish, avoid sharks, and try not to lose their minds—these scenes are
fantastic, engrossing in ways the movie never achieves again. While no more or
less harrowing than the other events Jolie shows, these scenes in the ocean are
the only times where any meaningful human interaction takes place.
Seriously. It’s also the only part of Unbroken in
which the actors have anything substantial to do.
O’Connell has won a ton of critical acclaim this year for
his turns in films like Starred Up and ’71.
Many expected Unbroken to be his coming out party,
and while he’s far from incompetent, the film affords him little besides the
opportunity to stare into the middle distance for long stretches of time.
Unbroken is exactly the movie you
expect to see—which is a shame, because Zamperini’s account is so incredible.
Jolie has been part of the public consciousness for so long that it’s easy to
forget that this is only her second directorial effort. But working from a
script by the Coens, you had to hope that she wouldn’t rest on the laurels of
the story itself; you had to hope that she wouldn’t count on a revered
cinematographer to carry the burden of her breakout; you had to hope for more. [Grade: C]